27 Comments
User's avatar
Ren 🤍's avatar

I completely agree on the physical books. It’s how I learned and how my kids learned too. There’s something almost magical about the smell and feel about books. I always think about “You’ve Got Mail” and how Meg Ryan’s characters love and appreciate books so much. I’ll always opt for a book if it’s one of my favorite authors. I love building a “library” that I can hopefully pass along to my kids one day.

Expand full comment
Izzy | The Sunday Reads's avatar

Yes, for sure! That’s a brilliant idea.

Expand full comment
Joe Mullich's avatar

People get passionate on this topic, but I don't see it as a competition. I enjoy the tactile feel and romance of a physical book. But I also enjoy the ease and portability of an ebook (such as the ability to read on my phone if I find myself with a spare moment). I also enjoy audio books, and the ability to consume them when I am walking or biking. I used them each at different times for different reasons.

Expand full comment
Izzy | The Sunday Reads's avatar

I think this is such a great take. I too use both and like both for different reasons!

Expand full comment
Joe Mullich's avatar

Yeah, to me the bottom line is while anyone can have their own personal preference, anything any individual does is fine. I do think writers tend to be more into the romance of publishing. So we like the idea of seeing a wall of books and the idea of the "permanence" of printed books, even if some of those things are more emotional than reality. Readers are hard to attract and keep, so I am grateful if people consume my writing in any form or on any platform.

Expand full comment
Izzy | The Sunday Reads's avatar

I completely agree. It’s definitely more romanticized for myself and other writers to have that physical copy.

Expand full comment
JP Maulgue's avatar

I've always preferred physical books. recently got into the habit of only buying second hand books as well. when i start reading, i always wonder who would have read this before i did. plus there is soo much more to choose from..

Expand full comment
Louise's avatar

Same! Even better if there’s a handwritten message in the front.

Expand full comment
Tierah Ruins Things's avatar

I tried an ereader and it didn't work for me (for reasons that are too long to get into here), I just didn't like it. I will go for second-hand books for things I know I want to keep and read more than once, but I'll try a library too, before I look to purchasing new books (and, again, then only if it's one I'm sure I'll want to keep).

Moving is always a challenge when I have half of my boxes filled with books!

Expand full comment
Izzy | The Sunday Reads's avatar

Hi! Thanks for your comment! I’m moving soon and that’s actually part of the reason I made this - I’m dreading having to move all my books lol!

Expand full comment
Tierah Ruins Things's avatar

I hired a moving company the last time, it was well worth it! I also choose the smallest boxes for the heaviest things, like books.

Expand full comment
Izzy | The Sunday Reads's avatar

I think that might have to happen this time!

Expand full comment
Izzy | The Sunday Reads's avatar

Yes!! I love a good second hand book.

Expand full comment
Louise's avatar

I love a physical book and even take them with me on holiday.

Expand full comment
Izzy | The Sunday Reads's avatar

Me too! Bringing two with me next month :)

Expand full comment
Patricia Krohn's avatar

Love me some physical books. They are the best. However like you, when traveling nothing beats an ereader. There is a section of your newsletter that I always get confused by. Probably a me thing and everyone else gets it. The Top Reads. Are those your top reads from last week that were on the lists or ...?

Expand full comment
Izzy | The Sunday Reads's avatar

Hi! Apologies for any confusion - those are books that have recently joined the bestseller lists so not my own top reads!

Expand full comment
Patricia Krohn's avatar

gotcha

Expand full comment
Vulkan's avatar

Whilst I do love a physical book and have my own little library at home, The space restrictions you have on a warship means that I do have a LOT of books on my Kindle.

Expand full comment
Izzy | The Sunday Reads's avatar

Yes the kindle is super helpful when you lack space!

Expand full comment
Charlotte Rains Dixon, MFA's avatar

Great rundown of the difference between Ebooks and physical copies. I still prefer to hold a book in my hands. But I am ever so grateful for my Kindle when I'm traveling, like now. It enables me to take as many books as I want along with me in case I get bored. Or finish a book faster than I think!

Expand full comment
Izzy | The Sunday Reads's avatar

Thank you! I completely agree that the kindle is so helpful and convenient for traveling.

Expand full comment
Soph's avatar

I'm currently writing my next Substack which is going to be about my Kindle. There's just something about physical books, though - as you say, they amplify the joy of reading.

Thank you for sharing the upcoming releases, I know "I Hope This Finds You Well" is a romance but that would be *such* a good name for a horror/thriller!

Expand full comment
Izzy | The Sunday Reads's avatar

Can’t wait to hear what you have to say! And yes, that would be such a great title for a thriller!!

Expand full comment
Jim in Alaska's avatar

I quite agree. I've roughly a hundred feet of book shelving loaded with pleasure as well as reference. I just checked & I've 683 ebooks in my computer.

Paper & ebooks have a place in today's world & we mustn't loose sight of the value of both.

Expand full comment
Izzy | The Sunday Reads's avatar

I completely agree!

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment deleted
May 19, 2024
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
Izzy | The Sunday Reads's avatar

Thank you! It definitely helps to disconnect. The kindle is really nice to travel and ease of use, but I’d look into a kobo because you can annotate them!

Expand full comment